[
Sitemap ]
Voigt Pipe Project
C. Joye 6/01
|
Voigt pipes were a creation of
P.G.A.H. Voigt in the 1930's which are similar to the concept of a
transmission line, except the speaker is placed near the center of the
horn-shaped pipe. Since this is intended to be a full-range, single
speaker sound source, the type of speaker chosen is rather critical. One
of the favorites is the Radio Shack #40-1354A, a very versatile driver
that had a whizzer cone to aid the high frequencies, and good overall
tonal balance for a mere $10 -- until they discontinued it. Some very
excellent Voigt pipes were
constructed for well under $50. The triangular nature of the Voigt pipe
causes its resonant frequencies to be spread across the midrange bands,
and the
length of the pipe accentuates the bass frequencies very well. Because of
this, the Voigt pipe can produce a very wide frequency range with very
natural tonal balance.
|
Herbert
Jeschke's Voigt pipe
|
Eeehaah's
Folded Voigt pipe
|
O'Heocha D2-Al2
|
- After deciding that I needed some speakers in my basement (I had 12
tube amplifiers, an ancient pair of cheap two-way speakers with one woofer
that literally melted when a 6550 failed, and a test pair of little 6.5"
speaker boxes!), I decided that the Voigt pipe would be the way
to go. I had my
eye (but not my wallet) on a pair of $2400, polished aluminum D2-al2's
from O'heocha
Design, but decided to build a simple Voigt pipe instead. I already
had two 5" drivers that I hoped would do the job. They are not full range
drivers and I have no idea what their Qts is. They don't have great high
frequency extension, but I didn't mind because I wanted to use my plasma tweeters for the highs. They do have
awesome low frequency characteristic that I hoped the Voigt pipe would
bring out.
- I went to Home Depot and got a very nice sheet of 3/4" Birch Hardwood
plywood for $42. I was bent on building both pipes from one sheet, so
mine are only 7.5" wide and 9.5" deep (I wanted to preserve the 7 degree
angle that Jeschke used). They stand ~74" tall at the moment (with
the bottom attached) and I located
the speaker center at 39" above the floor. I used liquid nails and tub
caulk to glue and seal the boxes, with a few nails in the back panel.
- I put a few nails inside the pipe to hold the stuffing in there. I
bought a 5lb bag of Acousta Stuf from Parts Express, as well as some gold binding posts.
- I used ~1.2 lbs of stuffing per pipe in the upper half.
- The sound was surprisingly good for a pair of midbasses. The high
frequency extension was a little weak, but thats what my plasma tweeters
are for. The midrange was very full and clean, and the bass was strong
down to about 50Hz. I heard details in music I had never heard before.
The biggest problem was doppler distortion at high volume levels (~95dB)
due to
the excessively heavy cone. It makes trumpets sound a little like they
are under water when a large bass note hits (like the Olympic Fanfare,
Starwars theme, Star Trek theme from the Telarc CD I used). The cure
would be for me to get a subwoofer. I have my eye on a Pheonix Gold
Cyclone Sub, which is made for car audio, but is the most bizzare speaker
I have ever seen (it looks like a washing machine agitator, and works
like an Archemedian screw compressor).
- I have been listening to these for several hours now and they sound
really really good with the plasma tweeters. The midrange definition and
presence is amazing. The bass doesn't quite come out and grab you, but
it's definetely there, and very accurate and well-defined. I
need a sub for the lower frequencies. I want to listen to them all
day and night. I have gotten used to the level of bass they produce: I
think it's not that they are weak, but that I am used to listening to bass
a few dB louder than it should be in my car (need to combat road and wind
noise by increasing bass). I think these pipes are the best sounding
speakers I have heard for under $100, and my friend says they sound better
than most big 3-way speakers he's heard. I love the
single-speaker wide-bandwidth sound now.
The fast transient response of such wide-bandwidth systems just makes the
sound so smooth, like a well built horn-loaded speaker. My system diagram.
|
My Voigt pipe
|
My Voigt Pipe
|
Stereo setup
|
- Parts List:
- 4'x8' (3/4" thickness) Birch hardwood sheet (around A-B grade):
$42.00, Home Depot
- Two 5.25" midbasses, 50W each: $8.00 (clearance), Parts Express
- Two sets of Gold binding posts: ~$2 each, Parts Express
- 2.4lbs of Acousta Stuf: ~$15, Parts Express
- 7 feet of 2x14gauge copper speaker wire: ~$4 Parts Express
- Half-tube of Liquid Nails: ~$1, Hardware store
- Half-tube of Alex Plus caulk: ~$1, Hardware store
- Two piece of Dynamat: ~$2, Parts Express
- Eight self-stick rubber feet: ~$3, Radio Shack
- Total estimate: $85.00
- Obviously, the wood was my biggest expense. If you happen to have a
pair of good cheap speakers, like the RS 40-1354a, enough scrap wood, and
an old wool blanket, there's no reason you couldn't build an excellent
Voigt pipe for less than $20.
- What's next? I want to get a subwoofer so I can high-pass filter the
Voigt pipes around 60Hz. I don't think I'll low-pass filter the Voigt
pipes, they cut off pretty naturally around 3kHz with these "heavy-coned"
speakers (their cones are not really heavy at all, in fact they're
probably lighter than most midrange cones. They are just a bit too heavy
for pure full-range sound). I think I will build another pair since I'm so
pleased with
these, but this time using a Lowther driver, or Lothx driver because a
very light cone is very important (but they typically cost $300 each!!).
I would like to try the folded Voigt pipe and would like to make them
longer so I can used them without a sub. I may try making one three-sided
with all sides being triangular (different-sized triangles?). See
Voigt Pipe II plans.
|
|
The Equations I found for Voigt pipes seem to match up well with my
version (see right). I think these equations are for a fully stuffed
pipe, because mine seems to drop off around 55Hz, and it's about 60%
stuffed.
|
|
[
Sitemap ]
|