Currently, in the
largely exclusive field of high-end audio, there is an ever-growing market
for better
quality audio transducers. These transducers have come in the form of
normal dynamic cone speakers, electrocstatic sheet speakers, magnetic
ribbon speakers, magnetoplanar speakers, flat-panel NXT speakers, and ion
speakers. By far the most used speaker is the dynamic speaker, which uses
a permanent magnet and electromagnet to create sound by way of a rigid
cone. These dynamic speakers come in all sizes for woofers
(low-frequency), mid-ranges (mid-frequency), and tweeters (high
frequency). The largest problem with dynamic speakers, or any speaker,
for that matter, is the weight of the cone. In a dynamic speaker, the
electromagnet must quickly accelerate and deaccelerate the cone. This is
not much of a problem in low-frequency drivers, but in many cases, it
becomes the limiting factor to how well a high-frequency driver will
sound. Electrostatics get around it a little by using a large sheet of
extremely thin conductive plastic, kind of like Saran Wrap, but they have
their limitations too. The same applies to magnetoplanars and ribbon
tweeters, which use a very light weight metal element. The NXT speakers
use a proprietary piezo-like film and heavy signal processing to create
sound from complex surface vibrations. That leaves ion speakers.
The
Ionophone, also known as the
Ionovac or IonoFane, was invented around 1946 by Siegfried Klein, makes
use of the corona discharge effect to create sound from the
air itself. Using the air as the sound emitting medium and also the sound
transmitting medium means that there is no mass to move in order to create
the sound. The corona simply heats the air very rapidly to produce nearly
perfect sound. With no mass to accelerate, the ion speaker has
theoretically perfect transient response- the ability to instantaneously
respond to an infinitesimally short pulse. One problem which limits the
usability of this method of creating sound it would require a very large
volume of corona to produce low frequencies. Large corona means high
voltage. Think of the power used by lightning bolt to create its
tremendously low frequencies. An ionic device to create such low
frequencies would likely be prohibitively impractical. But regular
dynamic speakers handle low frequencies very well, so only mid- and
high-frequency sound would really show a markable improvement by using an
ion speaker.
Besides the remarkable transient
response of an ion tweeter, they have one other major advantage over any
other type of tweeter: They are as near to a true point-source of sound
as possible. This means that the sound emitted is equally dispersed in
all directions, 360 degrees. No matter where you stand in a room with a
pair of ion tweeters, you get the same clean sound. The stereo image
does not change from one area of the room to another because the frequency
spectrum is the same in all directions. Regular tweeters have optimal
frequency spectra on axis. Once you move off of the axis, the frequency
spectrum changes and the stereo image is degraded. Because the ion
tweeters disperse sound 360 degrees, they require a larger amount of power
to produce the same amount of sound as a dynamic tweeter. Ion tweeters
can become quite loud if the room they are placed in is carefully designed
to reflect some sound without causing echos. Early ion tweeters used a
horn-shaped shroud to focus the sound in one direction (see Ionovac
picture above, left). This horn increased the otherwise low volume output
of the early ion tweeters, but also added multipath reflections which
can cause sound fidelity degradation if the horn is not properly
engineered. A properly engineered horn can have advantanges besides
increasing loudness, namely extended low-frequency response. The top-most
right photo shows an ion tweeter without a horn. By increasing the audio
signal to the corona, the audio sound output level can reach very high
levels on the order of 110dB or higher (measured near-field).